Skip to content

NSINorth Star Intel

ICD 203 analytic standards

ICD 203 is Intelligence Community Directive 203, the United States directive on analytic standards. The Office of the Director of National Intelligence issued it in 2007 and revised it in 2015. It sets five analytic standards and nine tradecraft standards. This page explains each one and how North Star applies it.

ICD 203 at a glance

Full name
Intelligence Community Directive 203, Analytic Standards
Issued by
Office of the Director of National Intelligence (ODNI), United States
First issued
June 21, 2007
Current version
Signed January 2, 2015, with technical amendments since
What it sets
Five analytic standards, nine analytic tradecraft standards and seven likelihood terms
What it governs
The analytic products of the United States Intelligence Community

Analytic standards

Objective

What ICD 203 says

Analysis applies the highest standards of integrity and rigor, identifies and challenges assumptions and considers alternative perspectives.

How North Star applies it

The Decision Record saves the key assumption, an indicator that would disprove it and a plausible alternative explanation.

Related record

Independent of political consideration

What ICD 203 says

Assessments are not distorted by advocacy, a preferred outcome or the audience's wishes.

How North Star applies it

Sealing requires a reviewer who is not on the receipt's account. Priority comes from a published formula, not from who asks.

Related record

Timely

What ICD 203 says

Analysis is delivered while it can still inform the decision it supports.

How North Star applies it

Every decision carries an owner and a deadline. The Daily Brief shows what changed since yesterday and the evidence due today.

Related record

Based on all available sources

What ICD 203 says

Analysis uses all relevant information available and notes gaps that affect its judgments.

How North Star applies it

Records cite each attached source with its observation date. Missing evidence stays missing and is never filled in.

Related record

Implements the tradecraft standards

What ICD 203 says

Analysis follows the nine analytic tradecraft standards listed below.

How North Star applies it

Each standard below names the matching field or rule in North Star Vision.

Analytic tradecraft standards

Describes the quality and credibility of sources

What ICD 203 says

Identify the sources behind a judgment and describe factors that affect their quality and credibility.

How North Star applies it

Each source gets reliability A to F and information credibility 1 to 6. Ungraded means no assessment was recorded.

Related record

Expresses and explains uncertainty

What ICD 203 says

State the confidence in a judgment and explain the basis for it.

How North Star applies it

Low, moderate or high confidence is saved with a written reason, the assessor and the time. Confidence is not priority.

Related record

Distinguishes information from assumptions and judgments

What ICD 203 says

Keep underlying information separate from the analyst's assumptions and judgments.

How North Star applies it

Records label each line as an observed fact, an inference, a prediction, a human attestation or a verified outcome.

Related record

Incorporates analysis of alternatives

What ICD 203 says

Consider other explanations or outcomes, especially when uncertainty is high or the stakes are significant.

How North Star applies it

The assessment saves a plausible alternative explanation and a fallback owner. The pre-mortem tool asks what would make the decision fail.

Related record

Demonstrates relevance and addresses implications

What ICD 203 says

Tie the analysis to what the reader must decide and explain the consequences.

How North Star applies it

Each record names the decision question, the expected result and the business implication, with a review deadline.

Related record

Uses clear and logical argumentation

What ICD 203 says

Present a main judgment first, then the reasoning and evidence that support it.

How North Star applies it

The decision card leads with the decision, owner and deadline, then confidence, evidence and outcome in a fixed order.

Explains change or consistency of judgments

What ICD 203 says

Say whether a judgment has changed from earlier analysis and why.

How North Star applies it

Saved record history keeps prior snapshots. A material edit invalidates the owner's authorization until it is given again.

Related record

Makes accurate judgments and assessments

What ICD 203 says

Apply expertise and logic to reach judgments that are as accurate as the information allows.

How North Star applies it

Outcomes are checked against a record before they are called verified. A signature proves integrity, not causation.

Related record

Uses effective visual information

What ICD 203 says

Use charts and graphics where they clarify the analysis.

How North Star applies it

The Index and Daily Brief chart dated records only. Sample visuals are labelled illustrative.

Related record

How ICD 203 words likelihood

The directive gives each likelihood term a percentage range, so a reader knows what a word such as likely means.

TermRange
Almost no chance1 to 5%
Very unlikely5 to 20%
Unlikely20 to 45%
Roughly even chance45 to 55%
Likely55 to 80%
Very likely80 to 95%
Almost certainly95 to 99%

The scale stops at 99 percent. ICD 203 also tells analysts not to combine a confidence level and a likelihood term in the same sentence.

Questions about ICD 203

What does ICD 203 stand for?

ICD stands for Intelligence Community Directive. ICD 203 is the directive titled Analytic Standards, part of a numbered series issued by the Director of National Intelligence.

Who issued ICD 203 and when?

The Office of the Director of National Intelligence first issued it on June 21, 2007. The current version was signed on January 2, 2015 and has received technical amendments since.

What are the five analytic standards in ICD 203?

Analysis must be objective, independent of political consideration, timely, based on all available sources of intelligence information, and consistent with the analytic tradecraft standards.

What are the nine analytic tradecraft standards?

Describe source quality, explain uncertainty, separate information from assumptions and judgments, analyze alternatives, show relevance and implications, argue clearly and logically, explain changes in judgment, make accurate judgments and use effective visuals.

What do the ICD 203 likelihood terms mean?

Each term maps to a percentage range. Almost no chance means 1 to 5 percent, roughly even chance means 45 to 55 percent and almost certainly means 95 to 99 percent.

Does ICD 203 apply to private companies?

No. It binds the agencies of the United States Intelligence Community. The text is public, so any organization can read it and borrow its method for its own analysis.

How does North Star Intel use ICD 203?

As a public reference for how a Decision Record names its sources, states confidence with a reason and keeps information apart from judgment. Each standard on this page lists the field or rule that applies it.

Free decision log templateThe Evidence Contract

Summaries paraphrase the public directive. ICD 203 is a public analytic reference. North Star Intel has no government affiliation, clearance or certification, and this page is not a compliance claim. Methodology