Skip to content

NSINorth Star Intel

Methodology

A decision needs a reason. A verified outcome needs evidence.

Methodology

Verified receipt reading

IllustrativeAs of 2026-11-08

Decision
Add a second dispatcher before storm seasonJudgment
Owner
Dispatch lead
Deadline
2026-11-21
Priority
88 / 100
Confidence
Moderate confidenceTwo seasons of dispatch logs agree. The hiring timeline is untested.
Evidence
FactDispatch log export, phone systemB2Usually reliable · Probably true
Verified outcome
Pending until the indicator is checked against a record.
Seal fingerprint
sha256:3f9c…a1e7

Sample decision, not a client's record. Decision, owner, evidence fingerprints, verdict, dates and the hashed seal are signed receipt fields at the publish level the client chooses. Confidence, source grades and the key assumption are saved on the Decision Record and are not part of the signed v1 format. How we grade evidence

Assessment reference

These are scale definitions, not grades assigned to this page. Confidence is separate from priority. A source grade does not verify an outcome.

UnassessedLow confidenceModerate confidenceHigh confidence
A1Completely reliable · ConfirmedB2Usually reliable · Probably trueC3Fairly reliable · Possibly trueD4Not usually reliable · DoubtfulE5Unreliable · ImprobableF6Cannot be judged · Cannot be judged–Ungraded

Reliability A to F and credibility 1 to 6 are independent judgments, not fixed pairs. Ungraded stays ungraded.

What ICD 203 requires

ICD 203 describes objective analysis, independence from political considerations, timeliness and use of all relevant available information. Its tradecraft standards address source quality, uncertainty, assumptions, alternatives, relevance, logical reasoning, changes in judgments, accuracy and clear visuals. We use it as a public analytic reference, not a certification.

Related recordRead ICD 203

Priority is not confidence

Priority comes from opportunity, risk of waiting and effort, using the published scoring method. It is not a probability of success or a confidence grade. People confirm the ratings.

Related record

State what is known

Separate observed records, inferred explanations, predictions, human attestations and verified outcomes. Record the source and observation date. Missing evidence stays missing.

Related record

Assess the source and the information

The Decision Record saves a human assessment for each attached source. Reliability uses A: completely reliable, B: usually reliable, C: fairly reliable, D: not usually reliable, E: unreliable, F: cannot be judged. Information credibility uses 1: confirmed, 2: probably true, 3: possibly true, 4: doubtful, 5: improbable, 6: cannot be judged. Ungraded means no assessment was recorded. These separate Admiralty-style scales are not prescribed by ICD 203. A grade does not validate a file or verify an outcome.

Explain uncertainty

The Decision Record saves low, moderate or high confidence with a written reason and the assessor’s account and time. Low means substantial gaps or conflicting information. Moderate means a credible basis with important limits. High means strong, consistent supporting information, not certainty. Unassessed stays unassessed. Confidence is a human judgment, not priority or event probability. These labels are our assessment convention, not a scale required by ICD 203.

Name the assumption that could fail

The assessment saves the key assumption, an indicator that would disprove it, a plausible alternative explanation and a fallback owner. Evidence that conflicts with the preferred explanation belongs in the record. An assumption is not an observed fact, and a recorded fallback owner is not authorization to act.

Authorization is not a typed name

Account-owner authorization records the signed-in account, time and a fingerprint of the decision’s material fields. A material edit invalidates that authorization. A typed approver name does not replace it. Recorded authorization does not claim that an external system executed an action.

Related record

Trace the source and its age

The Daily Brief uses account-owned records and dated change history. Its as-of time is not the age of every source. Observation dates and source references establish freshness. Private-file validation reads the account-owned file, records its SHA-256 fingerprint and storage version, and does not certify that its contents are true. Assessment fields are not part of the existing signed receipt format.

Explain why a judgment changed

State the decision question, the relevant evidence, the reasoning and what would change the assessment. Record the business implication and a review deadline. Saved record history retains prior snapshots so reviewers can compare a changed judgment with its earlier basis. No missing history is reconstructed.

Verify the record, not a promise

A signed receipt can be checked for integrity. A signature does not prove causation or guarantee a business result. Sealing requires independent review and distinct evidence. Publication requires the customer’s consent.

Related record

Analytic standards reference

ICD 203 is a public reference for distinguishing evidence, assumptions and judgment. North Star Intel has no government affiliation, clearance or certification. This page describes our method and its current limits, not compliance certification.

Read ICD 203